cookie (37)
Sort by
Img 20190420 123820

Lava Cookies Chocolate Chip Lava Cookie: These massive cookies (about 4" in diameter and 3/4" thick) are available at pastrami shop Harry and Ida's in the East Village. Each cookie costs a little under $6 each and are large enough to be easily shared. I'm not one to purchase a cookie in a bake shop, as I generally prefer other pastries and breads, but I can easily say this is one of the top cookies I've had in my life. On the interior is a molten chocolate filling whose consistency just holds together, while the cookie itself is... (read more) 4.5/5.0

4.5 cookie lava chip chocolate lavacookies harryandidas nyc baked exceptional
Img 20190913 181916

Michel et Augustin Milk chocolate and melt caramel shortbread cookie squares: About the size of a candy bar, this snack consists of four 1.5" square-shaped shortbread cookies, each with a generous milk chocolate well and a thin layer of stretchy salted caramel sandwiched underneath. Definitely one of the best store-bought cookies I've ever purchased. The shortbread have a perfect snap, and the balance of sweet and savory is ideal. Even though the caramel is thin, it has a rich, buttery flavor and flakes of salt that add texture. The cookies are made in France and ... (read more) 4.5/5.0

parkslopefoodcoop 4.5 squares cookie caramel melt milk micheletaugustin milkchocolate chocolate shortbread biscuit sweets cookies exceptional
990754595453306410 1397986312

Honolulu Cookie's Hawaiian fruit shortbread cookie: An assortment of pineapple shaped cookies, each with a piece of dried fruit at the center. Individually wrapped. The pineapple flavored one I had was very good. The shortbread was buttery and crumbly, and the dried fruit was flavorful with just the right amount of sweetness. 4.0/5.0

honolulucookie Hawaiian recommended cookie fruit pineapple sweets honolulucookies shortbread 4.0
1045311548711798002 1397986312

365 ginger snap cookies: Solid spiced ginger flavor. Cookies have the perfect level of crunch-not too thick or dense. Sweetness from molasses is not overpowering. Great with milk. Very good budget snack. 4.0/5.0

365 wholefoods gingersnaps ginger cookie recommended sweets 4.0 snap cookies
1111267196032812741 1397986312

Trader Joe's triple ginger cookie thins: I really like these cookies. They have an unapologetic ginger flavor, and the texture is slightly crispy. They have a better ginger flavor than Anna's Swedish cookies, and they still have a satisfying bite without the thickness of normal ginger snaps. Highly recommended. 4.0/5.0

traderjoes cookies ginger cookiethins 4.0 recommended sweets triple cookie thins
13557078 1547214775587986 1109335419 n

Annie's lemon drop cookie bites: Crumbly, shortbread-like lemon cookies that have a very good tangy citrus flavor. Amount of lemon is just right. One of the better lemon cookies I've had in recent memory. 4.0/5.0

annies lemon cookie 4.0 recommended drop bites